Alphabetical List of Peanut Butter for Dogs: SAFETY Check

If you do not see a peanut butter listed, you can leave a comment and we will get it added pronto!

One of our top picks for Dog Safe Peanut Butter can be SHIPPED to your door. It is the 365 brand that is sold at wholefoods and on amazon. You can click the jar picture and be taken to the actual product to check current pricing.

NO Filler Oils! NO Sugars! NO Salt! Just 100% organic Dry Roasted Peanuts!

How to Use This Dog Peanut Butter Database

Mobile Phone Users, Turn Your Phone Sideways to See All Columns.

To check for Xylitol content, or whether or not a peanut butter is safe to give your dog you can use this list 3 Ways:

1 – Type the 1st Few Letters of Your Peanut Butter into the Search Bar.

2- Sort By Dog Friendliness – Simply Click the Column “Dog Friendliness and all the best peanut butter for dogs will be at the top.

3 – Scroll through the table, all peanut butters are listed alphabetically.

Start Typing Your Peanut Butter

Brand VersionDog
Friendliness
Problem Dog
Ingredients
Can Cause
365 Everyday Value
Organic Creamy
No salt or Sugar
BestNoneHappiness!
Adams
Creamy
Crunchy
FriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt
Aldi (aka)
Peanut Delight
Creamy
Crunchy
WarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Added Soybeans
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Brad's
Organic
Natural
BestNoneHappiness!
Brandless
Organic CreamyFriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt
Chef's QualityCreamyWarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Crazy Richards
Creamy
Crunchy
BestNoneHappiness!
Earth BalanceNatural CreamyWarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Go NuttsMost
Versions
DeadlyXylitolLiver Failure
Seizures
Death
Great Value
(Walmart)
Creamy
Crunchy
WarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Added Molasses
Added Glycerides
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
JifCreamy
Natural
WarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Added Mono and Diglycerides
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Justin'sClassicWarningAdded OilsDiarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Kirkland
Organic CreamyFriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt
KrogerRegular Creamy
Regular Crunchy
WarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Kroger NATURALNatural Creamy
Natural Crunchy
FriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt
Laura Scudder
Old Fashioned
Creamy
FriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt
MaranthaOrganicWarningAdded OilsDiarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
My Protein
All NaturalBestNoneHappiness!
No CowMost
Versions
DeadlyXylitolLiver Failure
Seizures
Death
Nutts N' MoreMost
Versions
DeadlyXylitolLiver Failure
Seizures
Death
Nutty By NatureMost
Versions
DeadlyXylitolLiver Failure
Seizures
Death
Once Again
Organic
Creamy
Crunchy
BestNoneHappiness!
P28Most VersionsDeadlyXylitolLiver Failure
Seizures
Death
Peanut Delight
(Aldi)
CreamyWarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Added Soybeans
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Peter PanCreamyWarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Prince & Spring
Organic CreamyFriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt
Santa Cruz
Organic CreamyFriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt
Simple TruthNo-Stir CreamyWarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
SkippyNatural CreamyWarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Smart BalanceAll Natural CreamyWarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Smuckers
Natural CreamyFriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt
SurefineCreamyWarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Added Mono and
Diglycerides
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Teddie's
Smooth UnsaltedBestNoneHappiness!
Trader Joe'sCreamy UnsaltedBestNoneHappiness!
Wegman'sCreamy
Crunchy
WarningAdded Sugars
Added Oils
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Obesity
Cavities
Diabetes
Wild Friends
Natural CreamyFriendlySaltSafe Unless
Dog Can't
Have Salt

Please SHARE this on Social Media. We are trying to raise awareness for toxic peanut butter for dogs and would like everyone to check their pantry and buy safe peanut butter for their dogs.

For more information on xylitol inside peanut butter, read our other article here: Xylitol Toxicity in Dogs. It has more information plus links to our preferred peanut butter for dogs.

Thanks for visiting SeniorDogDays!

Sharing is caring!

Related posts

12 Thoughts to “Alphabetical List of Peanut Butter for Dogs: SAFETY Check”

  1. Chuck Houck

    Please check if the following brands contain xylitol: PEANUT DELIGHT distributed by ALDI, CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER disributed by LIDL.

    Thanks.

    1. D@SeniorDogDays

      No Xylitol, but this brand is labeled DOG WARNING. Peanut Delight distributed by Aldi (Creamy) has sugar listed as the 2nd ingredient. Then it goes on to include Hydrogenated vegetable oils, soybean, molasses etc. We will update the Aldi Section to include the name: Peanut Delight. Thanks for catching that Chuck!

  2. Michele

    Does Kroger brand creamy peanut butter contain xylitol?
    Does Wal-Mart brand creamy peanut butter contain xylitol?

    1. D@SeniorDogDays

      Hi Michele, Walmart (Great Value) and Kroger do NOT contain Xylitol but their regular creamy and crunchy fall under “dog warning” due to the added sugars and added oils. Good news on Kroger NATURAL creamy or NATURAL crunchy as they are going to be dog friendly. So if you like Kroger, stick with the jars labeled “Natural” and you’ll see ingredients listed as Dry Roasted peanuts and Salt- We will get them added to the database.

  3. Mia

    Great Value brand peanut butter is not on your list.

    1. D@SeniorDogDays

      Thanks Mia! Great Value would be a dog warning and here are the ingredients….Ingredients: PEANUTS, SUGAR, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF: FULLY HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OILS (COTTONSEED, SOYBEAN, RAPESEED), DEXTROSE, SALT, MOLASSES, MONOGLYCERIDES. We will get Great Value Peanut Butter Added to the Database.

  4. Lina

    Is Freedoms Choice Creamy peanut butter okay for dogs ?

    1. D@SeniorDogDays

      Looks like this is a commissary brand of peanut butter and we cannot find the ingredients listed anywhere for the creamy version. We found another version of Freedom’s Choice peanut butter and it contained Sugar, Molasses, Hydrogenated oils and rapeseed oils. At this point, we’ll call it dog warning and If anyone has a picture of a creamy Freedom Choice Peanut Butter label, can you please submit it to our comment section? Thanks Lina!

  5. Michael

    How about almond butter Costco brand

    1. D@SeniorDogDays

      Hi Michael, while Costco sells many brands of peanut butter, we cannot find a peanut butter labeled “Costco”. If you have this information, please upload a picture for us. Thank you!

  6. DeLane

    Could you check out Wegman’s brand of peanut butter, please.

    1. D@SeniorDogDays

      Hello DeLane, good one! Here is the scoop on Wegman’s Peanut Butter Ingredients: Roasted Peanuts, Sugar, Contains Less than 2% of Fully Hydrogenated Vegetable Oils (Rapeseed, Cottonseed, Soybean), Salt, Molasses. Therefore, we will mark this as Dog Warning! Thanks so much for stopping by and contributing!

Leave a Comment